WASHINGTON - Despite a troubled history, a federal judge cannot strip
the Interior Department of its management of
billions of dollars of royalties from Indian land, according
to government attorneys.
Because Congress assigned the Interior Department the task of
fixing the trust, a judge would be violating Congress'
constitutional authority if he changed that arrangement, the
department's lawyers argued in court documents filed late
Thursday night.
U.S. District Judge Royce Lamberth has been asked by lawyers
for 300,000 Indians to take away oversight of the Indian
money from Interior because the department has failed to fix
more than a century of mismanagement.
The trust fund was established in 1887 to manage mining, oil
and gas, timber harvesting and cattle grazing royalties from 54
million acres of Indian land.
Money from the account was meant to be paid to the Indian beneficiaries,
but the Indian plaintiffs say the Interior
Department squandered more than $10 billion.
In 1999, Lamberth ordered Interior to fix the system and account
for the lost money, but the department has failed to do
either despite spending $614 million on the effort, according
to reports by court-appointed watchdogs.
Because of the departments inability to fix the system, the Indians'
lawyers have asked Lamberth to find 39 Interior
Department officials in contempt of court and possibly jail
them.
In their recent filings, the Interior Department lawyers conceded
that Interior has struggled with reform efforts, but they
argued that the Interior Department officials have done nothing
to directly violate a clear court order which would justify a
finding of contempt.
At an Oct. 30 hearing, Lamberth scolded the Interior department's
lawyer, saying the department's behavior showed such
blatant contempt that he should "throw yourself on the mercy
of the court."
A hearing is tentatively scheduled for Nov. 30.